What are current security risks with using a Lenovo ThinkPad T430 with no microcode updates for Qubes OS?

I last followed Qubes years ago so forgive me if my knowledge is out of date.

My Qubes machine which has mostly been catching dust is the intel ME neutered + skulls T430, but I am interested in upgrading it to a newer machine now.

Last I was aware, the main risk of using that line of laptops was that a compromised VM could read the contents of another VM.

The Qubes team at the time advised not running sensitive VMs at the same time as non sensitive VMs to mitigate the risks.

I was considering the T480, but it also doesn’t get microcode updates.

I am considering dishing out cash for a certified laptop, but they’re mighty expensive.

Of course it depends on the threat model and it always is a game of case and mouse, but:

Assuming you’re not some kind of very high interest target, I want to give at least some confidence using that T430 without spending additional money:

  • OS and kernel software updates already provide protection against various Spectre v2 variants.
  • Spectre v2 is one of the more complex exploits, which also makes them unattractive to use from a benefit-cost ratio.
  • It is my impression newest variant(s) currently are rather of academic research interest.
  • Last remember, that Spectre v2 is a readonly exploit. For hard mitigation, you might follow that advice to shutdown potentially compromised VMs, when using sensitive VMs, to not leak data via memory.

+1 on that!
Tried and true older machines that have been out in the wild for a while, although maybe slower, and not as nifty but they have been battle tested in the wild for longer and vulns have been more apparent.

So, personally I take that into account. For highrisk stuff even now I still go back to my x230 :wink:

op mentioned T480, and not have security updates. Any one want to suggest security risks possible? Contrast Libre-Boot T480 versus using anti-evil maid with the disk key on a separate USB key?

Yep, re. the TPM Vuln. Having the Boot files on a ext. usb / SDCard is a good idea. (IMO that vuln is much more of a worry than Spectre.)

Re some of the newer machines IIRC Clevo had an issue where their signing keys were leaked.

https://undercodenews.com/clevos-security-meltdown-intel-boot-guard-keys-exposed-firmware-trust-chain-compromised/

Which was a pretty big serious thing at the time.