Some KDE system tray icons are blank

User Support
1

I have sys-net’s network icon and sys-usb’s blueman icon completely blank in system tray.

Are there any updates since 2016’s opened issue?

I use fedora as default template and KDE.

2

If the Issue discussion has no new information about it, then most likely there is no news. The developers have too few resources and too many bugs to fix, so any help would be appreciated.

3

Trying to understand what are my alternatives here.
Search gives just bunch of unresolved issues regarding the subject, plus no adequate alternatives.

I can help with identifying/reporting the issues, if it’s going to be addressed.
That networking icon alone is giving a one huge bubble of bugs.

4

I’ve been exploring this issue. I found out a way to reproduce it easily and a workaround.

The issue

So reading the different comments here and there and with my personal experience, we see that some icons show a white square (for example network manager applet for sys-net, or bluetooth applet for sys-audio) but some icons appear correctly (like sdwdate-gui for Whonix or VLC).

Let’s check the source code for the working applets:

sdwdate-gui: sdwdate-gui/usr/lib/python3/dist-packages/sdwdate_gui/sdwdate_gui.py at master · Kicksecure/sdwdate-gui · GitHub
VLC: vlc/modules/gui/qt/dialogs/systray/systray.cpp at master · videolan/vlc · GitHub

Both are using Qt’s QSystemTrayIcon class. And nm-applet used for network manager is GTK3. So we can assume from here that GTK is buggy but not Qt.

Tests

To test it better, let’s create a simple system tray icon in python.

GTK3 / AppIndicator3:

#!/usr/bin/python3
import os, gi

gi.require_version("Gtk", "3.0")

from gi.repository import Gtk as gtk, AppIndicator3 as appindicator


def main():
  indicator = appindicator.Indicator.new("customtray", "actor", appindicator.IndicatorCategory.APPLICATION_STATUS)
  indicator.set_status(appindicator.IndicatorStatus.ACTIVE)
  indicator.set_menu(menu())
  
  gtk.main()


def menu():
  menu = gtk.Menu()
  
  exittray = gtk.MenuItem('Exit Tray')
  exittray.connect('activate', quit)
  menu.append(exittray)
  
  menu.show_all()
  return menu
  

def quit(_):
  gtk.main_quit()


if __name__ == "__main__":
  main()

GTK3 / pystray:

import pystray

from PIL import Image

image = Image.open("icon.png")

def after_click(icon, query):
    if str(query) == "Exit":
        icon.stop()

icon = pystray.Icon(
        'testname', image, 'Test Name',
        menu=pystray.Menu(
            pystray.MenuItem("Exit", after_click)
        )
    )

icon.run()

If you run these two scripts in an appVM, it will display the buggy white square. The rest is working (Left-click on it shows the menu with a border of the appVM’s color).

Qt5:

from PyQt5.QtGui import *
from PyQt5.QtWidgets import *

app = QApplication([])
app.setQuitOnLastWindowClosed(False)

# Create the icon
icon = QIcon("icon.png")

# Create the tray
tray = QSystemTrayIcon()
tray.setIcon(icon)
tray.setVisible(True)

# Create the menu
menu = QMenu()
action = QAction("A menu item")
menu.addAction(action)

# Add a Quit option to the menu.
quit = QAction("Quit")
quit.triggered.connect(app.quit)
menu.addAction(quit)

# Add the menu to the tray
tray.setContextMenu(menu)

app.exec_()

Now this script displays the icon correctly.

Summary

So to sum up, the issue occurs with GTK3 icons. We still need to investigate why, but we know that using Qt icons work as expected.
Another thing will be to try using KDE instead of XFCE in a template, maybe it will at least fix network and audio widgets.

5

Also because this only occurs in KDE, can we update the title?

6

@PeakUnshift : Done, I updated the title…

2 Likes
7

I didn’t quite get it, did you manage to make the icon of the network work or just some random icon?
If it’s the network icon, can you please show how you did it exactly, as I don’t really want to lose my settings in case it goes sideways?