Should we require users to provide an edit reason for wiki posts?

[fsflover]

@alzer89

@fsflover

Did you actually experience any cases when that would improve anything on this forum?

I have. Accountability of your words.

No, I mean actual links to posts in which somebody made an edit which made the post worse, without providing a reason, after the grace period.

@unman

There is already a grace period of 10 minutes, after which all further edits are visible for everybody. I’m not sure if it only works for ordinary posts.

This simply is not so.
None of these edits are visible to users who interact with the Forum
via email. This bears repeating.

What are you talking about? Above I linked to the discussion about the email users. In that discussion it’s explained that these users can see the edits made until the grace period:

@Sven

After those 10 minutes your post gets sent to the email users.