Lenovo Legion 5i (15imh05h)

Hello again @51lieal - I went ahead and purchased the machine. I cannot get the QubesOS installer from GRUB to pass through and get a familiar error in the community: “Failed to start udev”. What were your relevant BIOS setting changes? So far I have:

  • Boot order to USB first
  • Use of “Dynamic Graphics” instead of “Discrete Graphics” from UEFI menu
  • Disable Secure Boot

Did you append anything to the Xen command line from GRUB like mentioned here?

UPDATE 1: Disabled UEFI and only enabled Legacy BIOS support and the “Failed to start udev” error went away entirely but I have been sitting at a black screen for 40+ minutes…
UPDATE 2: Screen finally after 2+ hours showed that /root could not be mounted and was unresponsive to a USB keyboard or on-board keyboard input, cursor is rapidly blinking about 10x faster than it normally would (I presume)
UPDATE 3: I tried the latest ISO from the test branch: Qubes OS openQA: qubesos-4.1-install-iso-x86_64-Build4.1.202303180203-install_default_kernel_latest@hw10 test results and can’t even get GRUB to show up
UPDATE 4: Found @51lieal comment which they should have put in the notes when reporting the YAML file update steps taken or linked to this comment: Qubes 4.1 on Legion 5 pro R7 5800H RTX3060 - #10 by 51lieal. Downloading the same ISO on the same hardware and will try to follow these exact steps. A link to this comment should be in the notes for the YAML. Will try once I have the beta ISO downloaded and BIOS is configured.
UPDATE 5: When editing the line for Install as suggested in UPDATE 4 I had to remove the part of the line which had i915.alpha_support=1 between plymouth.ignore-serial-consoles and quiet so now the part of the line is: plymouth.ignore-serial-consoles quiet i915.force_probe=* and I get a blank screen for 30+ minutes…

what machine? 15imh05h? or another legion?

I am now going to try this…

  1. use this iso https://mirrors.edge.kernel.org/qubes/iso/Qubes-R4.1.2-x86_64.iso

  2. use uefi only

  3. use discrete graphic

i’ve seen that you are using old release, also what gpu?

and how you make your qubes install medium?

I tried to replicate your exact findings back in 2021 from this comment: Qubes 4.1 on Legion 5 pro R7 5800H RTX3060 - #10 by 51lieal

oh i see, if you want testing you can use this https://openqa.qubes-os.org/tests/69041/asset/iso/Qubes-4.2.202303150603-x86_64.iso

it is r4.2, i’ve been using it for 1month+ and its stable.

From a Mac machine I write to USB with:

sudo dd if=Qubes-R4.1.2-x86_64.iso of=/dev/rdisk4 status=progress bs=1048576 conv=fsync

I get these graphics when I just now tried with Qubes-R4.1.2-x86_64.iso

yes it happen to me too, what configuration is that? uefi + discrete only?

Correct.

When I switch to “Legacy” at least no bad graphics but you think it should be using UEFI? Here are the rest of settings:



what gpu is it? mine is 1660ti.
i encourage to use uefi since it easier to troubleshoot even you break qubes.

you can just use 4.2 its fine, if uefi+dynamic / discrete not work.

Wait! Something happened… no longer getting messy screen graphics. I think “Dynamic” and not “Discreet” might have been set somewhere but took me saving it again for it to take to the system

This was back when I first started today though… Graphics is 1650ti

Are you able to image a disk with the Qubes-R4.1.2-x86_64.iso and check all the UEFI/BIOS settings you and I have are the same? The only difference would be you have 1660 vs I have 1650… Do I still need to add the i915.force_probe=* - this was a suggestion you had from a long time ago? I have added that and still udev failure…

with 4.1 i dont need any kernel parameters.

Hmmmm… Any other things you think you may have enabled/disabled in the BIOS? I can turn off other features like Intel Thermal section etc. Also, did you have an external keyboard/monitor hooked up? Mouse? etc.

nope

no

i think no.

i have state this long ago.

your best bet is perhaps using 4.2 or i’ve seen that you have windows, try using rufus with gpt style for 4.1.2

These instructions are outdated: UEFI troubleshooting | Qubes OS