High chance of polarising crisis actors acting as forum visitors

Hey y’all just a friendly heads up, since I lurk around in a lot of places I have noticed the last few dozen weeks that non-mainstream forums like this, video channel comments, mailing lists or basically anywhere people gather are all full with discord actors, “people” sharing your opinion but at the same time arguing against you and anyone sharing your opinion in general, making up facts or stories that individuals with less knowledge in the matter would read and automatically believe, I’m not sure if its just ai agents spreading FUD in general or its source but I am quite sure its happening, I think state level actors are looking to build up chaos, make new users less likely to stick to such groups like this forum or even spread false info to new users who are unlikely to associate long term with such a bubble and will return to another bubble of their own to continue spreading false info there, I honesty wouldn’t be posting this but the rate or way the information “changes” feels identical to forex moves, like someone is manufacturing emotional liquidity or consensus liquidityin chat groups and then breakout to their argument or if it doesn’t work DROP the argument and change the tactic with a new user handle, or at least this is a repeating pattern I have noticed,

All I can tell y’all is keep your emotions in check and your critical mind sharp, technocracy is here, take care.

Edit: look at the “solution” and my answer to it

Our community has the cognitive framework:

Whether it’s here now or not, it’s sure to come someday. A natural consequence of:

  • concentration of wealth and power,
  • a democratized information medium used daily by most people on the planet (the internet),
  • high-capability generalized automation mechanisms that take money/energy as input.

Given these three, the internet eventually becomes a battleground of persuasion and propaganda. Not great! Like @FranklyFlawless said, people who are drawn to projects like Qubes tend to have a healthy skepticism so one hopes we are as well equipped as anyone to weather the storm.

Like many here, I am generally suspicious, both of negative and positive personae.

I’ve noticed that a number of questionable accounts seem to have been created some time ago - even 6-9 months. Assuming that the suspicion is not misplaced, it is interesting that there is such preparation and investment of effort, although it is often seen with the “sockpuppet” problem.

Whatever social motivation there might be, we also need a regular practical reminder for this particular forum:

Great link for the subject, but I hope everyone treats these guidelines

I totally agree, I feel like this is being manufactured to push permanent digital IDs but without secure software and verifiable hardware digital ids are just sherfdom with extra steps

Thanks for bringing this up. I’ve noticed this exact thing happening here in the forum, not on a massive scale yet, but some threads by completely new users do seem to be spreading a lot of FUD.

Actually, I think we have a way less FUD then we had in the previous, let’s say 8-10 years.

Some advice, you should say what you mean rather than vague implication. Because when you speak vaguely, the thoughts behind your words will never be the same as the thoughts evoked in the minds of your readers, as they are in a different context to you and have different associations. It’s not unlikely they will come away believing you are saying something you deeply disagree with!

I am marking this as a solution because it is in fact a very good point.

Also in my defense I was always good at noticing things that happen behind the scenes and group events together so when something major happens I can link the dots and figure out a potential plan that has taken place but at the same time I am bad at explaining things because I don’t know the full picture in general, its not exactly instinct but more like trained experience that I cannot put into words yet, in other words I’m moderately good in the subject not a pro so I can point at things but not explain in detail if you catch my drift

There is another possible explanation: society as a whole evolves (what you describe here is consistent with my generic experience in physical “public” groups). Combine that with the fact that it is much easier to “polarize” online and you have another picture.

I’m not saying it is true or not. But, while your original post was appealing, I had to remind myself to be skeptical: there is a much simpler explanation than the one you are proposing. You could also consider that the part of the society participating in forums evolves? (I.e.: before joining in, I never heard someone using those terms seriously: “freedom of speech”, “woke”, “cancel culture”, etc.)

  1. So what?
  2. Who exactly is this topic for?
  3. Couldn’t it be said that even the OP itself can be considered as FUD? Just read it again, but from that perspective, and you might get the FUD vibe from it (commies enemy within point).
  4. Squeeze, then watch who’s screeching.

Admirable humility, but my comment was actually directed toward @corporateblush. The forum software auto-removed my quote, making it appear I was speaking to you, the OP. Ironic, when talking about vagueness.

So in the spirit of “say what you mean”, what I mean is I have no idea how to understand “Actually, I think we have way less FUD then we had in the previous, let’s say 8-10 years.” Sure, a few things in the discourse of the online world are clearer than they used to be, but broadly the people of planet Earth are drowning in FUD. It has not been a reassuring trajectory.

Sorry, I don’t understand your point, so I can’t respond. The fact that no one understood who you were talking to, actually can prove what you wrote in it. So much about “vague implication”, “the thoughts evoked in the minds of your readers”, etc…

Reading your comment as sincere: what I am asking is, what do you mean when you say there is way less FUD than 8-10 years ago? Can you provide an example or two?

Yes I can:

This whole subforum was established as a “solution” after mass spreading FUD.

And now? We have a few dozens of posts spreading FUD this year.

That alone should be enough, and I am not willing to search the forum and google groups for you from this point on.

I’ve been following Qubes for at least 10 years, closely(!), and I know what I am talking about.

You can also ask @adw, @Sven @SteveC and others from that era.

Find and read Qubes Air topic too, for example.

Ok, fair enough. I understood your original post to be about the online world more broadly, not specifically this forum.

Oh, now I fully understand you. Thanks for clarifying.
Talking about 'more broadly", I agree, but I think it’s more about grifting than anything else.

While tbf I understand why you think I might be grifting, I feel no shame at all because in the circles I hang around this warning at this point in time is quite important, IMO we are in the midst of a global economic and sociologic, censorship and ideological war, I won’t call out any countries specifically to avoid to get too political but look at it from my point of view

I HAVE to follow forum rules which disallow politics

I ALSO HAVE to warn my brothers and sisters around the globe who want to keep their freedoms

I CANNOT achieve the above 2 objectives without being vague

@Coalms I don’t think anyone feels you are grifting :+1: It’s an ugly ass time in the world, no doubt about it. Good for you, following through on your conscience and convictions. We all should do the same.

Just want to say I strongly agree with the sentiments of the last two posts. I’ve been online for a very long time and I always deeply appreciated the internet but lately I really don’t want to be online anymore (mostly for reasons this thread mentions). I don’t think that change has occurred by accident.

I have substituted almost all of my internet time with reading physical books and the difference in my quality of life is significant.